Wow, I’m shocked that this is exactly feedback #29! Hawthornehedge/Christine, In my opinion your comment concerning idea of Mr. Age, one to “it’s probable although not necessarily certain”, is in fact in accordance with the main part I found myself attempting to make from the fanon concepts as a whole. I’m not claiming any of the concepts I elevated for dialogue Aren’t probable, just that they have been from really the only plausible interpretations off cannon. It appears to be some people believe that simply because a large number out-of fanfics or fansites help an idea, you to alone was research the theory is right. And they sign on the principle as well, whenever “a lot of other admirers cannot be wrong”, and you will, particularly when considering fanfic, try influences myself since the almost sluggish.

M create actually ever share with their child you to definitely he would wanted to get married another woman; I do believe your “offhand remark” principle and TTB’s concept which he is actually idealizing 1st, shed love, is actually each other possible

In addition do not know how positively she meant for us to need Peeta’s thoughts, 11 ages afterwards, from a thing that taken place when he is actually five years dated. Katniss by herself doesn’t apparently initially, asking, “Therefore, since we were five, that you don’t also observed various other girls? Yes Really don’t consider the idea you to “Mr. Meters forever loved Mrs. Elizabeth, concise that he cheated into the their partner along with her, and you can Prim try the effect”, is actually built! We really don’t know just how abusive Mrs. Yards really was, otherwise exactly how unhappy Mr. M to be real inside the wedding. Katniss sees that bout of physical and you can spoken abuse, and you can Peeta sources one to bout of spoken abuse. Mrs. Yards plus seems to have a broad character once the a beneficial “witch”.

M had no love for their whatsoever and just wound up with her on account of a decided wedding

But that doesn’t mean Mr. From the real-world, Lots of women date, get married, and certainly will profess undying fascination with men who happen to be abusive in order to its people and you will high school students. They make reasons to the punishment, and you can would select the idea of cheating on the mate repugnant. Very, I really don’t find any excuse why it goes without saying one to a great man hitched in order to an enthusiastic abusive lady would cheerfully cheating on her, more than a lady hitched to an abusive man would. As for as to why Mr.

I do believe one to Mr. M’s choices is basically probable in that in several abusive otherwise let down marriages, mothers have a tendency to look to the people, not this new companion, for psychological help, and frequently filipinocupid cijena whine regarding mate with the kid. Mr. Meters doesn’t do that. But observe that Peeta’s a reaction to his father’s confession, try “A coal miner? As to why did she need a beneficial coal miner if she could’ve got you? Are you aware that Seam/Vendor split, In my opinion another significant component of this new “Demure is simply Mr. M’s child” concept was an expectation that Everdeens was indeed the initial cross-classification pair in order to ever before exist from inside the D12, and therefore there is no ways Mr. Everdeen might have had blonde, blue-eyed ancestors just who passed away men and women genetics so you’re able to him, and you will whose genetics the guy ultimately enacted in order to Demure.

We lso are-take a look at the section of THG where P and K explore you to definitely, and you will Peeta in fact does not apparently believe it had been a giant deal: “I know that would excitement your mother and father, you preference a good girl about Seam,” I state. But I decided not to care quicker. Anyhow, if we enable it to be back, you won’t end up being an effective girl from the Seam, you’ll end up a beneficial girl regarding the Victor’s Village,” according to him. Peeta’s mommy indicated anti-Seam bigotry when she tries to chase Katniss out, and you can Peeta’s father got an individual cause to help you dislike individuals from this new Seam, or at least not require their sons marrying some body from that point. But that does not mean *all* Provider family members might have tossed a complement in the event the an infant dated otherwise partnered out of their category, disowned them, an such like.