Commonly when dates are offered, he’s considering having twenty four hours of your week you to definitely really does maybe not match with that go out because it inside actual records. One analogy takes place in Harry Potter and also the Prisoner regarding Azkaban whenever Sybill Trelawney describes sixteen Oct once the Tuesday, although 16 Oct 1993 is actually a saturday.

There are even contradictions within the courses in this region. Such as for instance, inside the Harry Potter in addition to Cup regarding Flames, each other step one September and you may 2 September are given due to the fact Mondays and you may, inside the Harry Potter therefore the Prisoner out-of Azkaban, Buckbeak’s demo is set with the 20 April, but careful parsing of your text suggests that it may has happened zero later on than just March.

Along with, inside the Harry Potter while the Cup out of Fire they do say the Champions have been selected on the Saturday 31 Oct, however, 31 Oct is actually a friday in the 1994.

Into the chapter 7 out-of Quidditch Through the Many years, they do say that first Quidditch Community Glass was held for the 1473. In the event the championship is actually kept all several years, which conflicts on the report inside Cup out-of Fire that the 1994 Industry Glass is the new 422nd. In the event that Quidditch From the Decades is useful, the fresh 422nd Quidditch Community Cup carry out actually belong the year 3161, in case Cup out of Flame is right, the initial Globe Cup ended up being kept into the 306.

Historic dilemmas [ ]

While the collection, depending on the schedule derived from the Chamber regarding Secrets reference, is decided from the 1990s, the brand new show tend to appears as if it is place in new later nineties to help you middle-2000s, about concurrent to your publication of the instructions. From inside the Harry Potter together with Half-Blood Prince, Cornelius Fudge uses a masculine pronoun to mention with the “predecessor” of one’s Primary Minister of the United kingdom. According to the more than timeline, this would occur in the summertime regarding 1996, if the Primary Minister are John Major, whoever instant predecessor are a woman (is the reason very first interviewing Fudge, the ebook states new election, however, Significant wasn’t initial decided on and just took over immediately after Thatcher retired.

It’s possible, but not unrealistic, you to definitely Fudge was talking about a more faraway predecessor, because Thatcher took workplace ahead of Fudge allegedly turned into Minister having Wonders. (In the event you can thought a situation where Fudge try delegated of the Minister to own Secret to get to know into Prime Minister as he, Fudge, was at an inferior office.) At exactly the same time, the identity and you may reputation for the top Minister depicted seems to far more directly meets that Tony Blair than just regarding John Big. An article about Each day Post notes you to definitely Rowling try close into following-Chancellor of your own Exchequer Gordon Brown (usually viewed as a competition to help you Blair’s leadership of Work Class, exactly who been successful him and you will became Perfect Minister), and therefore she might have been attempting to reveal Blair’s poor side. In the event the books were place in connect with guide big date of Philosopher’s Brick, then so it skills carry out take place in 2002 (shortly after Blair turned Prime Minister).

Yet not, it absolutely was later on reported that twenty-two November try a monday, which it was in 1994

The same problem pertains to Nicolas Flamel, who was simply said as actually 665 during the time of the brand new first book, but Nicolas Flamel are a bona-fide historical contour and you will would not reach one to ages up to 1996, around the date the original publication is penned. The rebuttal for this is the fact that the time the newest “real” Nicolas Flamel was given birth to doesn’t talk to the fresh Nicolas Flamel off Harry Potter.

A special state is obtainable of Rubeus Hagrid’s period since Hogwarts’s gamekeeper. It’s required regarding collection one Hagrid obtained one status contained in this a few years of their expulsion regarding school in 1942. But in that scene away from Harry Potter and Goblet of Fire, Molly Weasley reminisces about Ogg, Hagrid’s preekeeper appear dating sites for bosnian women to convergence which have Molly’s ages in school, it looks unlikely you to she recalls a previous gamekeeper. Yet not, you’ll be able that Hagrid did not be a great gamekeeper quickly shortly after are expelled, but alternatively been since Ogg’s assistant. This is exactly possible since the when Harry believes that he often be expelled to have traveling with the broomstick as opposed to permission in his first 12 months, he wonders when the he’d be allowed to remain on as the Hagrid’s secretary.